Criticism of the Claim of Fawaz ibn Ahmad ibn Ali Rezwan about the Contradiction in Shiite Traditions on the Number of Imams (AS)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Theology and Islamic Studies, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran

2 Master's Student in Quran and Hadith Sciences, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

In the Shia hadith sources, in addition to many traditions that introduce the number of Shia Imams (AS) as twelve, there are other traditions that seem to conflict with them, citing the number of Imams other than twelve. Adducing these traditions, an Arabic article entitled "The conflict of the Rafezi narrated significations; a case study of Imamate" written by Fawaz ibn Ahmad ibn Ali Rezwan has claimed that the Shiite traditions regarding Imamate are contradictory and irreconcilable. Therefore, the principle of Imamate is a place of doubt. Using the descriptive-analytical method, the present research aims to answer the questions of the mentioned article about the number of imams. First, it quotes the claim and categorizes the traditions into seven groups: narrations of one imam, two imams, three imams, seven imams, twelve imams, thirteen imams, and twelve Mahdis after Qaem (Riser). Then, by examining the chain of transmission and the content of each tradition, it concludes that all of the traditions are weak in terms of their chain of transmission, and they conflict with the correct traditions in terms of their content, indicating the existence of twelve imams. In addition, some of them are incoherent. Assuming the acceptance of the chain of transmission and content of the traditions, the significations of some of them do not support the claim. On the contrary, they can be reconciled with the traditions indicating twelve imams.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

The Holy Quran
Al Buyeh, Ghanbar Ali; Ayati, Nosratollah. 2016. "Barresi Rewayat Janeshini Hazrat Rasul (S) wa Baz Tabyin Enhesar An dar Adad Dawazdah (Investigating the Narrations of the Prophet's Succession and Reinterpreting Its Exclusivity in the Number Twelve)", in: Promised East, no. 37, pp. 145-165. [in Farsi]
Askari, Mortaza. 2019. Men Hadith al-Nabi (S) Yakuno le Hazeh al-Ommah Ethna Ashar Ghiyama (From the Hadith of the Prophet (S) This Nation Will Have Twelve Values), n.p: n.pub. [in Arabic]
Ayati, Nosratollah. 2019. "Naghd wa Barresi Engareh Adam Enhesar Shomar Aemmah dar Adad Dawazdah (The Notion of Non-exclusivity of the Number of Imams in the Number of Twelve: Review and Critique)", in: Studies of Mahdism, no. 29, pp. 49-75. [in Farsi]
Dinewari, Ibn Ghotaybah. 1990. Al-Emamah wa al-Siyasah (Imamate and Politics), Researched by Ali Shiri, Beirut: House of Thought. [in Arabic]
Erbeli, Ali ibn Isa. 2002. Kashf al-Ghommah fi Marefah al-Aemmah (AS), Tabriz: Bani Hashemi. [in Arabic]
Estar Abadi, Mohammad Jafar ibn Seyf al-Din. 2009. Lob al-Labab fi Elm al-Rejal, Edited by Mohammad Bagher Malekiyan, Tehran: Osweh. [in Arabic]
Forat Kufi, Abolghasem. 1989. Tafsir Forat al-Kufi, Tehran: Printing and Publishing Foundation in the Ministry of Islamic Guidance. [in Arabic]
Helali, Solaym ibn Gheys. 1984. Ketab Solaym ibn Gheys al-Helali, Qom: Al-Hadi. [in Arabic]
Helli, Hasan ibn Yusof. 1981. Rejal al-Allamah al-Helli, Qom: Al-Sharif al-Mortaza. [in Arabic]
Horr Ameli, Mohammad ibn Hasan. 1983. Al-Ighaz men al-Hajah be al-Borhan ala al-Rajah, Tehran: Nawid. [in Arabic]
Ibn Babewayh, Mohammad ibn Ali. 1982. Maani al-Akhbar (Meanings of the Narrations), Researched Ali Akbar Ghaffari, Qom: Islamic Publications Office. [in Arabic]
Ibn Babewayh, Mohammad ibn Ali. 1992. Man la Yahzoroh al-Faghih (The One Who Doesn’t Have Access to a Jurist), Qom: Islamic Publications Office. [in Arabic]
Ibn Babewayh, Mohammad ibn Ali. 1999. Oyun Akhbar al-Reza (Selected Words of Imam Reza), Researched by Mahdi Lajewardi, Tehran: World. [in Arabic]
 
Ibn Babewayh, Mohammad ibn Ali. 2016. Kamal al-Din wa Tamam al-Nemah (Completion of the Religion and Perfection of the Grace), Researched by Ali Akbar Ghaffari, Tehran: Islamic Books House. [in Arabic]
Ibn Ghazaeri, Ahmad ibn Hosayn. 2001. Al-Rejal (Transmitters), Qom: House of Hadith. [in Arabic]
Ibn Hayyun, Noman ibn Mohammad. 1988. Sharh al-Akhbar fi Fazael al-Aemmah al-Athar (AS) (Explanation of the Narrations on the Virtues of the Pure Imams (AS)), Qom: Teachers Association. [in Arabic]
 Jawhari Basri, Ahmad ibn Abd al-Aziz. n.d. Moghtazab al-Athar fi al-Nas ala al-Aemmah al-Ethna al-Ashar, Qom: Tabatabayi Publications. [in Arabic]
Kashi, Mohammad ibn Omar. 1984. Ekhtiyar Marefah al-Rejal, Qom: Al al-Bayt (AS) Institute. [in Arabic]
Khazzaz Qomi, Ali ibn Mohammad. 1980. Kefayah al-Athar fi al-Nass ala al-Aemmah al-Ethna Ashar, Qom: Bidar. [in Arabic]
Kolayni, Mohammad ibn Yaghub. 1986. Osul Kafi, Tehran: Islamic Books House. [in Arabic]
Kufi, Mohammad ibn Solayman. 1991. Managheb al-Imam Amir al-Momenin Ali Ibn Abi Taleb (Virtues of Imam the Commander of the Faithful Ali Ibn Abi Taleb), Qom: The Revival of Islamic Culture Complex. [in Arabic]
Lotfi, Rahim; Shahbaziyan, Mohammad. 2017. "Barresi Gharaen Rewayi Enhesar Aemmeh (AS) dar Adad Dawazdah (Examining the Evidence of the Exclusivity of the Imams in Twelve)", in: Mahdavi Researches, no. 21, pp. 23-48. [in Farsi]
Majlesi, Mohammad Bagher ibn Mohammad Taghi. 1982. Behar al-Anwar al-Jameah le Dorar Akhbar al-Aemmah al-Athar (Vast Oceans of Light Containing the Selected Narrations of the Infallible Imams), Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]
Majlesi, Mohammad Bagher ibn Mohammad Taghi. 1983. Merat al-Oghul fi Sharh Akhbar Al al-Rasul (Mirror of Intellects in the Explanation of the Narrations of the Prophet's Family), Tehran: Islamic Books Institute. [in Arabic]
Musawi Borujerdi, Hasan. 2017. "Chera Kar Tekrari Nakonim? Naghdi bar Tahghigh Ketab Kefayah al-Athar Khazzaz Qomi (Why not Repeat the Work? A Critique on the Research of Khazzaz Qomi's Book Kefayah Athar)", in: Mirror of Research, no. 165, pp. 113-124. [in Farsi]
Najjashi, Ahmad ibn Ali. Rejal al-Najjashi, Qom: Islamic Publishing Corporation. [in Arabic]
 
Pahlewan, Mansur. 2013. "Barresi Ahadith Muhem Sizdah Imam dar al-Kafi (Examining the Important Hadiths of the Thirteen Imams in al-Kafi)", in: Imamate Studies, no. 12, pp. 257-262. [in Farsi]
Rezwan, Fawaz ibn Ahmad ibn Ali. 2020. "Taaroz Delalat al-Marwiyat end al-Rafezah; al-Imamah Anmuzajan (Conflict between the Significations of Rafezi Hadiths; Imamate as an Example)", in: College of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Girls in Alexandria, no. 36, pp. 140-190. [in Arabic]
Saedi, Hoseyn. 2005. Al-Zoafa men Rejal al-Hadith (Unreliable Transmitters), Qom: House of Hadith. [in Arabic]
Saffar, Mohammad ibn Hasan. 1983. Basaer al-Darajat fi Fazael Al Mohammad (S) (Insights Degrees in the Virtues of the Family of Mohammad), Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library. [in Arabic]
Safi Golpaygani, Lotfollah. 1998. Montakhab al-Athar fi al-Imam al-Thani Ashar (Selected Traditions about the Twelfth Imam), Qom: Lady Masumah Institute. [in Arabic]
Shahid Thani, Zayn al-Din ibn Ali ibn Ahmad. 1987. Al-Reayah fi Elm al-Derayah (Hadith Terminology), Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library. [in Arabic]
Shariati Sabzewari, Mohammad Bagher. 2009. "Imaman Dawazdahganeh dar Quran wa Sonnat (Twelve Imams in the Quran and Tradition)", in: Waiting for the Promised One, no. 30, pp. 5-27. [in Farsi]
Tabarsi, Abu Ali Fazl ibn Hasan. 1986. Elam al-Wara be Alam al-Hoda, Qom: Al al-Bayt (AS) Institute. [in Arabic]
 Tusi, Mohammad ibn al-Hasan. 1990. Al-Ghaybah (The Occultation), Qom: Islamic Teachings House. [in Arabic]
Tusi, Mohammad ibn al-Hasan. 1993. Al-Amali, Qom: House of Culture. [in Arabic]
Tusi, Mohammad ibn al-Hasan. 1999. Fehrest Kotob al-Shiah wa Osulehem (List of Shiite Books and Their Sources), Qom: Researcher Tabatabayi Library. [in Arabic]
Zeynali, Gholam Hoseyn. 2007. Dawazdah Janeshin: Pajueshi dar Bab Ahadith Kholafay Ethna Ashar (Twelve Successors: A Research on the Hadiths of the Twelfth Caliphs), Qom: Research Institute of Hawzeh and University. [in Farsi]
 

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics