A Review and Critique of the Hypothesis of Burning and Destroying Books by Muslim Conquerors in Early Works

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PhD Student in History of Islamic Civilization and Nations, Islamic Azad University, Qom, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of History of Islamic Civilization and Nations, Islamic Sciences and Culture Academy, Qom, Iran

Abstract

The importance of books and libraries is not hidden among civilizations. The destruction of books at some points in history has led to claims as to why it happened. Examining the works of our predecessors, we come across their claim that the books were destroyed by Muslim conquerors. Investigating and criticizing this claim is an issue that this article addresses. Making this claim in the present era against Islam and Muslims is a proof of the importance of addressing and criticizing the issue. This paper is organized by referring to libraries and sources related to the study of past works and by describing and analyzing them with the aim of criticizing the book burning claim and dismissing the accusation of Muslim conquerors. In this study, we have shown that the first question on the book burning issue arose five centuries after the advent of Islam. Ibn Khaldun, Abu Rayhan Biruni, and Samarkandi have been great scholars in various fields, but in the field of history, there have been reports of their carelessness in conveying historical material, including the claim that the Muslim conquerors destroyed the books, which is not accurate.

Keywords

References

Abu Rayhan Biruni. 2001. Al-Athar al-Baghiyah an al-Gharn al-Khaliyah (Remnants of Past Centuries), Tehran: Written Heritage. [in Arabic]
Aghighi Bakhshayeshi, Abd al-Rahim. 2008. Tabaghat Mofasseran Shiah (Classes of Shiite Commentators), Qom: Promise of Islam. [in Farsi]
Amin, Ahmad. 2004. Zoha al-Islam (Victims of Islam), Beirut: Scientific Books House. [in Arabic]
Arsalan, Shakib Amir. n.d. Tarikh Fotuhat Mosalmanan dar Orupa: Faranseh, Suis, Italiya wa Jazayer Daryay Meditaraneh (History of Muslim Conquests in Europe: France, Switzerland, Italy and the Islands of the Mediterranean), Translated by Ali Dawani, Tehran: Islamic Culture Publishing Office. [in Farsi]
Ayati, Abd al-Hamid. 1970. "Shoubiyyah Pishahangan Nehzat Esteghlal Talabi Iran (Shoubiyyah, the Scouts of the Iranian Independence Movement)", in: Education & Training, no. 119, pp. 6-0. [in Farsi]
Baghdadi, Abd al-Latif. 1869. Al-Efadah wa al-Etebar (Benefit and Credibility), Egypt: Nile Valley Press. [in Arabic]
Balazori, Ahmad ibn Yahya. 1996. Jomal men Ansab al-Ashraf (Overview of Aristocratic Genealogy), Beirut: Thought Institute. [in Arabic]
Browne, Edward. 1988. Tarikh Adabiyat Iran az Ferdosi ta Sadi (History of Iranian literature from Ferdowsi to Saadi), Translated by Fathollah Mojtabayi & Gholam Hoseyn Sadri Afshar, Tehran: Morwarid. [in Farsi]
Christensen, Arthur. 2015. Iran dar Zaman Sasaniyan (Iran during the Sassanids), Tehran: Glance. [in Farsi]
Dolatshah Samarghandi. 1900. Tazkerah al-Shoara (Memoirs of Poets), Leiden: Edward Brown.
Durant, Will. 2012. Tarikh Tamaddon (Story of Civilization), Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [in Farsi]
Ghafti, Jamal al-Din. 1992. Tarjomeh Tarikh al-Hokama: Doreh Shah Soleyman Safawi (Translation of the History of the Philosophers: the Period of Safavid Shah Suleiman), Tehran: University of Tehran.
Gordizi, Abd al-Hay. 1984. Tarikh Gordizi (History of Gordizi), Tehran: World of Book. [in Farsi]
Hadizadeh, Seyyed Nasrollah. 2011. Naghsh Mosalmanan dar Gostaresh Ketabkhaneh-ha wa Barresi Shobheh Ketabsuzi Tawassot Mosalmanan (The Role of Muslims in the Expansion of Libraries and the Investigation of the Issue of Burning Books by Muslims), Supervisor: Mostafa Moallemi, Master's Thesis in History, Islamic Azad University, Shahrood. [in Farsi]
Hajizadeh, Yadollah. 2013. Taamol Mosalmanan wa Iraniyan dar Fotuhat Islami: Barresi Barkhi Shobahat (The Interaction of Muslim Arabs and Iranians in Islamic Conquests: A Study of Some Doubts), Qom: Research Institute of Baqir al-Olum. [in Farsi]
Hojjati Kermani, Mohammad Jawad. 1973. "Khorafeh Ketabsuzi (Book Burning Superstition)", in: Lessons from the School of Islam, p. 14, p. 10, pp. 757-816. [in Farsi]
Ibn al-Abari. 1992. Tarikh Mokhtasar al-Dowal (Brief History of the States), Beirut: House of East, Third Edition. [in Arabic]
Ibn al-Nadim. 1998. Al-Fehrest (The List), Beirut: House of Knowledge. [in Arabic]
Ibn Khaldun, Abd al-Rahman. 1974. Moghaddameh Ibn Khaldun (Introduction of Ibn Khaldun), Translated by Mohammad Parwin Gonabadi, Tehran: Book Translation and Publishing Company. [in Arabic]
Ibn Khaldun, Abd al-Rahman. 1996. Moghaddameh Ibn Khaldun (Introduction of Ibn Khaldun), Translated by Mohammad Parwin Gonabadi, Tehran: Scientific & Cultural, Eighth Edition. [in Farsi]
Ibn Mekawayh. n.d. Mojmal al-Tawarikh wa al-Ghesas (Concise Chronicles and Histories), Tehran: Kalaleh Khawar. [in Arabic]
Khalifeh, Shaban Abd al-Aziz. 2002. Maktabah al-Eskandariyah al-Harigh wa al-Ahya (Alexandria School of Fire and Revival), Republic Book Series. [in Arabic]
Khorrami, Mostafa. 2014. Naghd wa Barresi Raftar-hay Siyasi wa Ejtemai Fatehan Mosalman dar Gharn Awwal Hejri (A Study and Critique of the Political and Social Behaviors of Muslim Conquerors in the First Century AH), Qom: Al-Mustafa International Translation and Publishing Center. [in Farsi]
Koleyni, Mohammad ibn Yaghub. 2009. Osul Kafi, Qom: Ajwad. [in Arabic]
Le Bon, Gustave. 1968. Tamaddon Islam wa Arab, Tarjomeh Hezarat al-Arab (Islamic and Arab Civilization, Translation of Arab Civilization), Written by Hashem Hoseyni, Tehran: Islamiyyeh Bookstore. [in Farsi]
Meghrizi, Ahmad ibn Ali. 2001. Khotat: Al-Mawaez wa al-Etebar fi Zekr al-Khotat wa al-Athar, London: Al-Furghan Foundation for Islamic Heritage. [in Arabic]
Minawi, Mojtaba. 1973. Barresi-hayi Darbareh Abu Rayhan Biruni (Studies on Abu Rayhan Biruni), Tehran: Supreme Council of Culture and Art. [in Farsi]
Moin, Mohammad. 1981. Farhang Farsi (Persian Dictionary), Tehran: Amirkabir. [in Farsi]
Momtahen, Hoseyn Ali. 1974. "Nehzat Shoubiyah wa Natayej Siyasi wa Ejtemai An (The Shoubiyah Movement and Its Political and Social Consequences)", in: Historical Studies, no. 51, pp. 1-32. [in Farsi]
Moradi, Nurollah. 1990. "Ketabkhaneh Eskandariyyeh, Motaleat Melli Ketabdari wa Sazmandehi Ettelaat (Library of Alexandria, National Library Studies and Information Organization)", in: Encyclopedia Britannica, no. 2-4, pp. 202-203. [in Farsi]
Mostofi, Abdollah. n.d. Sharh Zendegi Man (My Biography), Tehran: Pilgrims. [in Farsi]
Motahhari, Morteza. 2010. Majmueh Athar (Collection of Works), Tehran: Sadra, vol. 14. [in Farsi]
Murray, Stuart. 2009. The Library: An Illustrated History, New York: Skyhorse Pub.
Odi, Sattar; Ramezanipur, Gholam Reza. 2007-2008. "Emhay Ketabkhaneh-hay Iran wa Eskandariyeh dar Hamleh Arab (Destruction of Iranian and Alexandrian Libraries in the Arab Invasion)", in: Miskawayh, no. 8, pp. 157-180. [in Farsi]
Pishwayi, Mahdi. 2003. "Taammoli dar Athar wa Andisheh-hay Ibn Khaldun (A Reflection on the Works and Thoughts of Ibn Khaldun)", in: History of Islam in the Mirror of Research, Preprint 3, pp. 13-64. [in Farsi]
Purdawud, Ibrahim. 2006. Yasht-ha (Introduction to the Yashts), Tehran: Asatir. [in Farsi]
Rawandi Morteza. 2004. Tarikh Ejtemai Iran (Social History of Iran), Tehran: Glance. [in Farsi]
Rodkinson, Michael Levi. 1918. The History of the Talmud, from the Time of its Formation about 200 B.C. Talmud Society.
Rypka, Jan. 2002. Tarikh Adabiyat Iran az Doran Bastan ta Ghajariyeh (History of Iranian Literature from Ancient Times to Qajar), Translated by Isa Shahabi, Tehran: Scientific & Cultural. [in Farsi]
Safa, Zabihollah. 1999. Tarikh Adabiyat dar Iran (History of Literature in Iran), Tehran: Ferdos. [in Farsi]
Samani, Abd al-Karim. 1962. Al-Ansab, Heydarabad: Ottoman Encyclopedia. [in Arabic]
Sepehr, Mohammad Taghi. 2001. Nasekh al-Tawarikh, Tehran: Myths. [in Arabic]
Shahidi, Seyyed Jafar. 1974. "Athar al-Baghiyah wa Ketabsuzi dar Kharazm (Remnants and Book Burning in Khwarazm)", in: Jewel, no. 21, pp. 803-806. [in Farsi]
Tabari, Mohammad ibn Jarir. 1983. Tarikh al-Omam wa al-Moluk (The History of Nations and Kings), Beirut: Scientific Foundation for Publications. [in Arabic]
Tusi, Mohammad ibn Hasan. 1993. Al-Amali, Qom: House of Culture, First Edition. [in Arabic]
Zahabi, Shams al-Din Mohammad ibn Ahmad ibn Othman. 1998. Tarikh al-Islam wa Wafayat al-Mashahir wa al-Alam (History of Islam and the Deaths of Figures and Luminaries), Beirut: Arabic Book House. [in Arabic]
Zarrinkub, Abd al-Hoseyn. 2012. Karnameh Islam (Record of Islam), Tehran: Amirkabir. [in Farsi]
Zeydan, Jorji. 1994. Tarikh Tamaddon Islam (History of Islamic Civilization), Tehran: Amirkabir. [in Farsi]

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics