Infallibility: A Comparative Study of the Viewpoints of Imamiyyah and Zaydiyyah

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Graduate of the Forth Degree in Qom Seminary and Ph.D. in Shiology, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran

Abstract

Imamate and its related issues are among the important and controversial issues in the field of religious knowledge and thought of Shiite sects, especially Zaydiyyah and Imamiyah. The Zaydiyyah, although due to the verses of purification and explicit traditions believe in the infallibility of the companions of al-Kisa, they do not consider infallibility as a condition and a necessary attribute for the Imam and due to various reasons, including lack of rational and narration on the infallibility of the Imam, explanation of its reality and the meaning of infallibility have therefore adhered to the non-obligation of the divine decree in the appointment of an Imam. In addition, they also have disagreements with the Imamiyyah on its instances. The main purpose of this research is to list the reasons for rejecting Imam's infallibility from the Zaydiyyah’s viewpoint, to prove the Imam's infallibility and also to respond to the doubts of the Zaydiyyah in this regard. Naturally, a comparative study of the arguments put forth by both the sects and its analysis will have a significant impact on the explanation and the role of an Imam's position in society. The present article is library-based research with a descriptive and analytical approach that has been conducted around some of the reasons and arguments of both sects about the necessity or the unnecessity of the condition of infallibility for an Imam. The most important finding of this study, contrary to Zaydiyyah’s claim of Imamate about the unnecessity of the condition and attribute of infallibility for the Imam, in the Imamiyyah viewpoint, in addition to various narrative reasons, there are numerous rational reasons including Imam's existential philosophy, loss of position and denial of people, purpose violation, preservation and protection of religion, the necessity of the issue of infallibility and the successorship to the Prophet Muhammad indicate towards the infallibility of an Imam.

Keywords


Al-Mahdi Li Deenillah, Ahmad ibn Yahya (1985). Kitaab al-Qalaid fi Tashih al-Aqaid, Beirut: Daar al-Mashriq. [In Arabic]
Al-Mahdi Li Deenillah, Ahmad ibn Yahya (1987). Al-Bahr al-Zakhaar al-Jaame’ li mazaahib ulama’ al-Amsaar, Sana'a: Dar al-Hikmah al-Yamaniyyah. [In Arabic]
Al-Mansour Billah, Qasim bin Muhammad (1994), Kitaab al-Asaas li Aqaid al-Akyaas, Commentary by: Muhammad Qasim Abdullah al-Hashami, Saada: Islamic Heritage Library, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Al-Rassi, Muhammad ibn Qasim (2002). Majmua’ Kutub wa Rasail al-Imam Muhammad ibn al-Qasim al-Rassi, Research by: Abdul Karim Ahmad Jadbaan, Sa'da: Library of Islamic Heritage, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Ash'ari, Abul Hassan (1980). Maqalaat al-Islamiyin wa Ikhtilaaf al-Musalin, Germany - Wiesbaden: Frans Steiner, Third Edition. [In Arabic]
Bahrani, Ibn Maitham (1986). Qawaid al-Maraam fi ilm al-Kalaam, Qom: Ayatollah Al-Marashi Library, Second Edition. [In Arabic}
Bahrani, Ibn Maitham (1996). Al-Najat fi al-Qiyamat fi Tahqiq al-Amr al-Khilafat, Qom: Majma’ al-Fikr al-Islami, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Fazil Miqdaad, Husayni, Abulfattah bin Makhdum (1986). Al-Baab al-Hadi Ashar Ma'a sharihayhi al-Nafe’ yawm al-Hashr wa Miftaah al-Baab, Tehran: Institute of Islamic Studies, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Halabi, Abu al-Salah Taqi bin Najm (1983). Al-Kafi fi al-Fiqh, Isfahan: Imam Amir al-Momenin Ali (a) Public Library. [In Arabic]
Halabi, Abu al-Salah Taqi bin Najm (1984). Taqrib al-Ma’arif: Al-Hadi Publications. [In Arabic]
Hili, Hasan ibn Yusef (1984). Anwaar al-Malakut fi Sharh al-Yaqut, Research by: Muhammad Najmi Zangani, Qom: Al-Sharif Al-Radhi, Second Edition [In Arabic]
Hili, Hasan ibn Yusuf (1992). Manahij al-Yaqin fi Usul al-Din, Tehran: Dar Al-Uswah, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Houthi, Husayn ibn Yahya (2001). Al-Jawaab al-Kaashif li al-Iltebaas a’n Masaail al-Africi Ilyas wa Yalihi al-Jawab al-Raqi ala Masail al-Iraqi, Saada: Ahl Al-Bayt Center for Islamic Studies, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Babawayh Qommi (Saduq), Muhammad ibn Ali (2005). Kamal al-Din wa Tamaam al-Nia’m, Translated by: Mansour Pahlawan, Qom: Jamkaran Mosque, Third Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Babawayh Qummi (Saduq), Muhammad bin Ali (1991). Al-E’tiqadaat, Qom: World Congress of Sheikh Al-Mufeed, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Badr al-Din, Hussein (2001). Yanabi al-Nisihah fi al-Aqaid al-Sahihiah, Sana'a: Maktib al-Badr, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Fars ibn Zakaria, Abi al-Hasan Ahmad (1994). Miqyaas al-lughat, Qom: Islamic media office. [In Arabic]
Ibn Hamz al-Alawi, Yahya (N.p). Mishkaat al-Anwaar al-Haadimat li Qawaid al-Baatiniyyaht al-Ashraar, reseacrched by: Muhammad al-Sayyid al-Jalind, Cairo: Daar al-Fikr al-Hadith. [In Arabic]
Ibn Nobakht, Abu Ishaaq Ibrahim (1993). Al-Yaqut fi ilm al-Kalaam, Research by: Ali Akbar Ziyaie, Qom: Ayatollah Marashi Najafi Library. [In Arabic]
Ibn Noman (Mufid), Muhammad bin Muhammad (1993). Al-Nukat al-I’tiqaadi, Qom: The World Conference of Shaykh Al-Mufid, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Noman (Mufid), Muhammad bin Muhammad (1993). 'Awail al-Maqalaat fi al-Madhahib wa al-Mukhatarat, Qom: The International Conference of Sheikh Al-Mufid, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Nu’maan (Mufid), Muhammad bin Muhammad (1993). Tashih al-e’teqadaat al-Imamiyyah, Qom: World Congress of Shaykh Al-Mufid, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Ibn Numan (Mufid), Muhammad bin Muhammad (1993). Al-Jamal, Qom: The World Conference of Sheikh Al-Mufeed, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Kharrazi, Mohsen (1990). Bidayat al-Ma’arif al-Elahiyyah fi Sharh al-Aqaid al-Imammiyyah, Qom: The Center for the Management of the Seminary of Qom, Fourth Edition. [In Arabic]
Kulayni, Muhammad ibn Yaqub (1983). Al-Kafi, Tehran: Islamiyyah Publications, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Majlesi, Muhammad Baqir (1984). Bihar al-Anwaar, Beirut: Al-Wafa Institute. [In Arabic]
Muzaffar, Muhammad Reza (1996). Al-Mantiq, Qom: The Ismailiyan Institute, Seventh Edition. [In Arabic]
Nasir al-Din Tusi, Muhammad ibn Muhammad (1985). Talkhis al-Muhassal al-Ma’ruf bi Naqd al-Muhassal, Beirut: Daar al-Azwaa’, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Omerji, Ahmad Shuqi (N.p). Al-Hayaat al-Siyasiyyat wa al-Fikriyyat li al-Zaydiyyat fi al-Masharq al-Islami, Cairo: The Madbouly Library. [In Arabic]
Sharafi, Ahmad bin Muhammad (1991). Sharh al-Asas al-Kabir: Shafa’ Sudur al-Naas bi sharh al-Asaas: Research by: Ahmad Ata Allah A’arif, Sanaa: Yemeni House of Governance, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Sharafi, Ahmed bin Muhammad (1994). Iddat al-Akyaas fi Sharh Ma’ani al-Asaas, Sanaa: The Yemeni Government House. [In Arabic]
Subhani, Ja`far (1991). Al-ilahiyyat ala Huda al-Kitaab wa al-Sunnat wa al-Aql, Qom: The International Center for Islamic Studies, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Subhi, Ahmed Mahmoud (1990). Al-Imaam al-Mujtahid wa Aarauhu al-Kalamiyyah, Cairo: The Modern Age, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Tabataba’i, Muhammad Husayn (1992), Majmuey-e Maqalaat wa Pursesh ha va Pasukh ha, Tehran: Islamic Culture Publication Office, Second Edition. [In Persian]
Tabataba’i, Muhammad Husayn (1996) Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an, Qom: Islamic Publications Office, Fifth Edition. [In Arabic]
Tabataba’i, Muhammad Husayn (2009). Shia dar Islaam, Qom: Bustaan-e Kitaab. [In Persian]
Tusi, Muhammad bin Hasan (1986). Al-Iqtisad fi maa Yataa’laqo bi al-I’tiqaad, Beirut: Dar Al-Azwaa’, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Tusi, Muhammad bin Hasan (1994). Al-Rasa'il al-Ashar, Qom: Al-Nashr al-Islami Institute, Second Edition. [In Arabic]
Tusi, Muhammad bin Hasan (2003), Talkhis al-Shafi, Qom: Al-Muhibbeen Publication, First Edition. [In Arabic]
Tusi, Muhammad bin Hasan (N.p). Al-Tibyan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an, Beirut: Daar Al-Ehyaa’ al-Turath al-Arabi. [In Arabic]
Zaid bin Ali (2001). Majmua’ Kutub wa Rasail al-Imam Zaid bin Ali, Research and Edited by: Muhammad Yahya Salim A’zaan, Sana'a: Yemeni House of Government, First Edition. [In Arabic]