Journal of Imamiyyah Studies

Journal of Imamiyyah Studies

Investigating the Effect of the Foundations of Modernity on the Methodology of Understanding the Quran: Mahdi Bazargan & Abd al-Karim Sorush

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student in Teaching Islamic Studies, Payame Noor University, Qom, Iran
2 Associate Professor, Department of Islamic education, Payame Noor University, tehran, Iran
10.22034/jis.2023.313392.1735
Abstract
Studying Christian theology and confrontation of ideas in the West and theorizing about issues such as the nature of revelation, how the Quran was revealed, and the method of understanding it, the new intellectual current tried to create harmony between religion and modernity, which sometimes caused some aspects of religion and the Quran to fade in modernity. Mahdi Bazargan and Abd al-Karim Sorush are among the representatives of this current who, despite the difference in their views, had common foundations in the tendency towards modernity. Examining some foundations of modernity such as liberalism, humanism, secularism, positivism, religious pluralism, rationalism, pragmatism, historicism, and contemporary and philosophical analysis in the thought of these two religious intellectuals, the present article studies the language and method of understanding the Quran. According to the results of the research, although the way these two religious intellectuals deal with the theoretical foundations of modernity has similarities and differences, it has had a similar effect on the roots and context of their theorizing. The methodology of understanding the Quran from the point of view of Mahdi Bazargan can be analyzed in the framework of the simple components of modernism, but Sorush's theological approach goes with postmodern logic and the movement of libertarian theology.
Keywords
Subjects

The Holy Quran
Arab Salehi, Mohammad. 2016. "Mabani Tarikhmandi Quran wa Tahlil wa Naghd Mabnay Wahyshenakhti An (The Foundations of the Historicity of the Quran and the Analysis and Criticism of Its Revelational Basis)", in: Philosophy of Religion, yr. 13, no. 4, pp. 659-679. [in Farsi]
Arblaster, Anthony. 1988. Zohur wa Soghut Liberalism (The Rise and Decline of Western Liberalism), Translated by Abbas Mokhber, Tehran: Penguin. [in Farsi]
Asadi, Mohammad Reza. 2004. Danayi wa Mozal Dindari (Knowledge and the Problem of Religiosity), Tehran: Today's Thought. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1959 a. "Peragmatism dar Islam (Pragmatism in Islam)", in: Collection of Wisdom, no. 47, pp. 14-20. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1959 b. Rah Teyshodeh (Crossed Road), Tehran: Enteshar Joint-Stock Company. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1965. Zarreh Bi Enteha (Infinite Particle), Tehran: Scientific & Cultural. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1976. Seyr Tahawwol Quran (The Evolution of the Quran), Prepared by Seyyed Mohammad Mahdi Jafari, Tehran: Pen. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1981. Bethat wa Ideolojy (Beginning of Prophet's Mission and Ideology), Mashhad: Rising. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1983. Gomrahan: Hadithi Mofassal az Ghorun Wostay Masihiyat dar Ertebat ba Sureh Hamd (Misguided: A Detailed Hadith from the Middle Ages of Christianity in Connection with Surah Hamd), Tehran: Publication Center. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1985. Bazyabi Arzesh-ha: Majmueh Athar 25 (Restoring Values: Collection of Works 25), Tehran: Enteshar Joint-Stock Company. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1995. "Akherat wa Khoda: Hadaf Bethat Anbiya (Hereafter and God: The Purpose of the Prophets)", in: Kiyan, yr. 5, no. 28, pp. 46-61. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 1998. Padeshahi Khoda (Kingdom of God), Tehran: Enteshar Joint-Stock Company. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 2000 a. Peragmatism dar Islam, Majmueh Athar 7 (Pragmatism in Islam, Collection of Works 7), Tehran: Enteshar Joint-Stock Company. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 2000 b. Dars Dindari, Majmueh Athar 9 (Religion Lesson, Collection of Works 9), Tehran: Enteshar Joint-Stock Company. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. 2008. Majmueh Athar Bazargan (Bazargan's Collection of Works), Tehran: Enteshar Joint-Stock Company, vol. 8. [in Farsi]
Bazargan, Mahdi. n.d. Azadi Hend (Freedom of India), Tehran: Mohammadi Bookstore. [in Farsi]
Childers, J.; Hentzi, G. (eds.). 1995. The Columbia Dictionary of Modern Literary and Cultural Criticism, pp. 1-140.
Dabbagh, Sorush. 2009/04/29. "Ghaht Mana dar Miyan Nam-ha (Famine of Meaning among Names)", in: www.drsoroush.com/Persian/On_DrSoroush/P-CMO-20090429-GhahteMaana.html.
Dehshiri, Mohammad Reza. 2018. "Asibshenasi Rawesh-hay Tajziyeh wa Tahlil dar Tarikhnegari Enghelab Islami (Pathology of Analysis Methods in the Historiography of the Islamic Revolution)", in: History of the Revolution, no. 2, pp. 9-34. [in Farsi]
Ghoreyshi, Fardin. 2005. Bazsazi Andisheh Dini dar Iran (Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Iran), Tehran: Ghasideh Sara. [in Farsi]
Ismaili, Hamid Reza. 1989. Din wa Siyasat dar Andisheh Siyasi Moaser (Religion and Politics in Contemporary Political Thought), Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies. [in Farsi]
Khaki Gharamaleki, Mohammad Reza. 2005. "Bazargan dar Buteh Naghd (Criticism of Mahdi Bazargan)", Andisheh Club. [in Farsi]
Khosropanah, Abd al-Hoseyn. 2010. Asibshenasi Dinpajuhi Moaser (Pathology of Contemporary Religious Studies), Tehran: Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought, Second Edition. [in Farsi]
Khosropanah, Abd al-Hoseyn. 2013/06/25. "Quran Karim; Tanzil Robubi (The Holy Quran; Divine Descent)", in: https://iqna.ir/00AhnG. [in Farsi]
Malekiyan, Mostafa. 2009. Rahi be Rahayi (A Way to Liberation), Tehran: Contemporary View. [in Farsi]
Moinimehr, Saideh. 2010. Khastgah-hay Fekri Andisheh Mahdi Bazargan (The Intellectual Origins of Mahdi Bazargan's Ideas), Master's Thesis, Supervisor: Hadi Wakili, Mashhad: Ferdowsi University. [in Farsi]
Motahari, Morteza. 2003. Barresi Ejmali Nehzat-hay Eslahi dar Sad Saleh Akhir (An Overview of Reform Movements in the Last Century), Tehran: Sadra. [in Farsi]
Najafi, Musa. 2006. Falsafeh Tajaddod dar Iran (The Philosophy of Modernity in Iran), Tehran: International Publishing Company, Second Edition. [in Farsi]
Nasr, Seyyed Hoseyn. 2009. Marefat wa Manawiyat (Knowledge and Spirituality), Translated by Enshallah Rahmati, Tehran: Sohrewardi. [in Farsi]
Purfard, Masud. 2013. Suratbandi Roshanfekri dar Jomhuri Islami Iran (Intellectual Formulation in the Islamic Republic of Iran), Tehran: Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought. [in Farsi]
Rahimi, Ali Reza. 1989. Tafakkor Asr Jadid dar Orupa (New age Thinking in Europe), Tehran: Bethat. [in Farsi]
Rashad, Ali Akbar. 2009. Dinpajuhi Moaser (Contemporary Religious Studies), Tehran: Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought. [in Farsi]
Rudgar, Mohammad Jawad. 2004. "Risheh-hay Peydayesh wa Gostaresh Sekolarism (The Roots of the Formation and Spread of Secularism)", in: Thought Portico, no. 29, pp. 22-36. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1979. "Ma dar Kodam Jahan Zendegi Mikonim? (What World Do We Live in?)", Tehran: Message of Liberty. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1994 a. "Modara wa Modiriyat Momenan (Tolerance and Management of Believers)", in: Kiyan, yr. 4, no. 21, pp. 2-15. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1994 b. Ghabz wa Bast Teorik Shariat (Theoretical Contraction and Expansion of the Sharia), Tehran: Serat, Third Edition. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1995. "Mana wa Mabnay Sekolarism (The Meaning and Basis of Secularism)", in: Kiyan, no. 26, pp. 4-13. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1998. Serat-hay Mostaghim (Straight Paths), Tehran: Path. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1999 a. "Rahayi wa Yaghin be Rahayi (Liberation and Certainty of Liberation)", in: Kiyan, no. 48, pp. 2-9. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 1999 b. Bast Tajrobeh Nabawi (Expansion of Prophetic Experience), Tehran: Serat. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2002/09/05. Iran's Golestan. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2003 a. "Aghlgerayi Enteghadi (Critical Rationalism)", in: Doubt, pp. 28-41. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2003 b. "Edalat Momken (Possible Justice)", in: Reflection of Thought, no. 47, pp. 893-900. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2003/09/28. "Sokhanrani dar Daneshgah Westminster Landan (Speech at the University of Westminster, London)", in: New Yas Newspaper, no. 168. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2005/04/04. "Nakami Tarikhi Moslemin (Historical Failure of Muslims)", The Seventh Part, London Center for Monotheism, Eghbal Newspaper, no. 42. [in Farsi]
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2007. "Beshr wa Bashir: Pasokh Sorush be Ayatollah Jafar Sobhani (Beshr and Bashir: Sorush's Answer to Ayatollah Jafar Sobhani)", in: www.drsoroush.com.
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2012. "Shiah Mohtaj Reform Ast (Shia Is in Need of Reform)", in: www.rahesabz.net/story/51531.
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2013. "Mohammad Rawi Royay Rasulaneh:  Bazkhani Pishineh Monazereh beyn Doctor Abd al-Karim Sorush wa Mohandes Abd al-Ali Bazargan (Mohammad, the Narrator of the Prophetic Dream: Rereading the History of the Debate between Dr. Abd AL-Karim Sorush and Engineer Abd al-Ali Bazargan)", in: www.nedayeazadi.net.
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2014/02/05. "Bazargan  Positivist?", in: www.nedayeazadi.net/1392/11/7560.
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. 2016/05/26. "Royahay Rasulaneh; Zehi Kereshmeh Khabi ke be ze Bidarist (Apostolic Dreams; Maybe the Charm of Sleep Is Better than Waking up)", in: https://www.bbc.com/persian/tvandradio/2016/05/160526_pargar_arical_souroosh.
Sorush, Abd al-Karim. n.d. Dars-hay Elm Kalam Jadid (New Theology Lessons), Cassette no 19. [in Farsi]
Talei Ardakani, Mohammad. 2012. "Raweshshenasi Enteghadi Andisheh Ejtemai Doctor Sorush (Critical Methodology of Dr. Sorush's Social Thought)", in: Social Cultural Knowledge, no. 10, pp. 97-120. [in Farsi]
Turani, Ala. 2019. "Tathir Falsafeh Gharb bar Tafakkor Dini Moaser (The Influence of Western Philosophy on Contemporary Religious Thinking)", The Conference of New Developments in the Field of Science and Metascience), n.p: n.pub. [in Farsi]
Waezi, Ahmad. 2017. "Moruri Enteghadi bar Quranshenasi Mojtahed Shabestari (A Critical Review of Mojtahed Shabestri's Quranic Studies)", in: Seminary, yr. 34, no. 176, pp. 82-94. [in Farsi]
Waezi, Ali. 2006. "Aghlgerayi Enteghadi wa Naghd An (Critical Rationalism and Its Critique)", in: Islamic Theology, no. 59, pp. 91-105. [in Farsi]
Zakariyayi, Mohammad Ali. 1999. Daramadi bar Roshanfekri Dini (An Introduction to Religious Intellectualism), Tehran: Azariyun. [in Farsi]
Zarshenas, Shahriyar. 1994. Taammolati darbareh Jaryan Roshanfekri dar Iran (Reflections on the Intellectual Movement in Iran), Tehran: Leaf. [in Farsi]