Journal of Imamiyyah Studies

Journal of Imamiyyah Studies

Critical Discourse Analysis of Imam Ali (AS) on Imamate with Emphasis on Sunni Resources

Document Type : Original Article

Author
Assistant Professor, Department of Ahl-al-BaitStudies, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran
Abstract
Using content analysis method as well as critical discourse analysis approach based on Norman Fairclough method, this article explains the mindset and outlook of Imam Ali (AS) while analyzing his discourse on Imamate. The discourse of "appointed Imamate", as opposed to the discourse of "elected leadership" which introduces the opinion and consensus of community as the criterion for recognizing the leader, is a discourse that did not develop in the sociological context and, in turn, social thought moved towards the ideology of "choice" in the matter of prophetic caliphate. In defense of the ideology of divine power and leadership, Imam Ali (AS) presented his rational arguments and strategies at different times in order to prove his appointed succession by recording the document of the legitimacy of the genuine Islamic belief in the field of Imamate. Considering that the position of the appointed Imamate and its related discourse are emerging in Shiism, in order to accept the subject trans-religiously, the research is based on Sunni narrations and historical texts. The results indicate that Imam Ali (AS) by using linguistic and ideological structures in criticizing the ruling discourses sought to reproduce the prophetic discourse on guardianship and leadership.
Keywords

Al-Ajorri al-Baghdadi, Mohammad ibn al-Husayn. 1999. Al-Shariah (The Sharia), Researched by Abdollah ibn Omar ibn Soleyman al-Damiji, Riyadh: Dar al-Watan. [in Arabic]
Al-Albani, Mohammad Naser al-Din. 1995. Selselah al-Ahadith al-Sahihah wa Shay men Feghheha wa Fawaedeha (The Authentic Hadith Series and Some of Its Understanding and Benefits), Riyadh: The Teachings Library. [in Arabic]
Al-Balazori, Ahmad ibn Yahya. 1996. Ansab al-Ashraf, Researched by Soheyl Zakkar & Riyaz al-Zarkeli, Beirut: Institute of Thought. [in Arabic]
Al-Bokhari al-Jo‘fi, Mohammad ibn Esma‘il. 1987. Al-Jame‘ al-Sahih al-Mokhtasar, Researched by D. Mostafa Dib al-Bagha, Beirut: Ibn Kathir Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Hakem al-Neysaburi, Mohammad ibn Abdollah. 1990. Al-Mostadrak ala al-Sahihayn, Researched by Mostafa Abd al-Ghader Ata, Beirut: Scientific Books Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Heythami, Ali ibn Abi Bakr. 1987. Majma‘ al-Zawaed wa Manba‘ al-Fawaed (Collection of Appendages and Source of Benefits), Cairo & Beirut: Al-Rayyan Institute for Heritage, Arabic Book Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Heythami, Ali ibn Abi Bakr. 1992. Majma‘ al-Zawaed wa Manba‘ al-Fawaed (Collection of Appendages and Source of Benefits), Beirut: Al-Rayyan Institute for Heritage, Institute of Thought. [in Arabic]
Al-Nasayi, Ahmad ibn Shoayb. 1990. Al-Sonan al-Kobra (The Great Traditions), Researched by D. Abd al-Ghaffar Soleyman al-Bandari, Beirut: Scientific Books Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Razi, Fakhr al-Din Mohammad ibn Omar. 2000. Al-Tafsir al-Kabir aw Mafatih al-Ghayb (The Great Interpretation or the Keys of the Unseen), Beirut: Scientific Book Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Sakhawi, Mohammad ibn Abd al-Rahman. 1983. Fath al-Moghith Sharh Alfiyah al-Hadith, Beirut: Scientific Book Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Shokani, Mohammad ibn Ali. 2015. Fath al-Ghadir al-Jame‘ bayn Fannay al-Rewayah wa al-Derayah men Elm al-Tafsir (Comprehensive Opening between the Two Arts of Narrating and Understanding of Exegesis Science), Beirut: Institute of Thought. [in Arabic]
Al-Siyuti, Jalal al-Din Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Bakr. 1993. Al-Dorr al-Manthur (The Narrative Pearl), Beirut: Institute of Thought. [in Arabic]
Al-Siyuti, Jalal al-Din Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Bakr. 1993. Tarikh al-Kholafa (History of Caliphs), Researched by Mohammad Mohyi al-Din Abd al-Hamid, Egypt: Happiness Press.
Al-Tabarani, Soleyman ibn Ahmad. 1984. Al-Mojam al-Kabir (The Great Dictionary), Researched Hamdi ibn Abd al-Majid al-Salafi, Mosul: Al-Zahra Library. [in Arabic]
Al-Tabari, Mohammad ibn Jarir. 1992. Dalael al-Emamah (Evidence of the Imamate), Researched by Department of Islamic Studies, Qom: Printing and Publishing Center at Al-Be‘thah Foundation. [in Arabic]
Al-Taftazani, Masud ibn Omar. 1981. Sharh al-Maghased fi Elm al-Kalam, Pakestan: Nomani Teachings Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Tahawi, Ahmad ibn Mohammad. 1988. Sharh Moshkel al-Athar (Explanation of Difficult Works), Researched by Shoayb al-Arnaut, Beirut: Al-Resalah Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Tamim al-Basti, Mohammad ibn Habban. 1975. Al-Theghat (The Trustworthy), Researched by Al-Seyyed Sharaf al-Din Ahmad, Beirut: Institute of Thought. [in Arabic]
Al-Thalabi, Ahmad ibn Mohammad. 2002. Al-Kashf wa al-Bayan (Tafsir Thalabi), Researched by Abi Mohammad ibn Ashur, Beirut: Foundation for the Revival of Arabic Heritage. [in Arabic]
Al-Waseti (Ibn al-Maghazeli), Ali ibn Mohammad. 2003. Managheb Amir al-Momenin Ali ibn Abi Taleb Raziya Allah anh (The Virtues of the Commander of the Faithful, Ali ibn Abi Talib, May God Be Pleased with Him), Researched by Abo Abd al-Rahman Torki ibn Abdollah al-Wade‘i,  Sanaa: Literatures Institute. [in Arabic]
Al-Zahabi, Shams al-Din Mohammad. 1991. Note of Memorizers, Beirut: Scientific Book Institute. [in Arabic]
Amini, Abd al-Hoseyn. 2001. Al-Ghadir fi al-Ketab wa al-Sonnah wa al-Adab (Al-Ghadir in the Book, Tradition and Literature), Translated by Mohammad Taghi Wahedi, Tehran: Bethat Foundation. [in Farsi]
Baker, Paul; Ellece, Sibonile. 2011. Key Terms in Discourse Analysis, London: Continuum.
 
Fairclough, Norman. 2010. Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language, London: Longman.
 
Farahidi, Khalil ibn Ahmad. 19899. Ketan al-Ayn (The Book of Eye), Qom: Hejrat. [in Arabic]
Hashemi Khoyi, Mirza Habibollah. 1980. Menhaj al-Bara‘ah fi Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah (Ingenious Method in Explanation of Nahj al-Balaghah), Translated by Hasan Hasanzadeh & Mohammad Bagher Kamarehyi, Tehran: Islamic Library. [in Arabic]
Ibn Abi al-Hadid, Abd al-Hamid ibn Hebatollah. 1984. Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah le Ibn Abi al-Hadid (Explanation of Nahj al-Balaghah by Abi Al-Hadid), Researched by Ebrahim Mohammad Abolfazl, Qom: Ayatollah Mar‘ashi Najafi Library. [in Arabic]
Ibn al-Athir al-Jazari, Ezz al-Din. 1996. Osd al-Ghabah fi Ma‘refah al-Sahabah (Forest Lion in Recognition of the Companions of the Prophet), Researched by Adel Ahmad al-Refa‘I, Beirut: Foundation for the Revival of Arabic Heritage. [in Arabic]
Ibn al-Molaghghen, Omar ibn Ali. 1990. Al-Tawzih le Sharh al-Jame‘ al-Sahih, Riyadh: Dar al-Asemah. In Arabic]
Ibn Ghotaybah al-Dinewari, Abdollah ibn Moslem. 1967. Al-Emamah wa al-Siyasah (Imamate and Politics), Researched by Taha Mohammad al-Zeyni, Cairo: Al-Halabi and Partners Institute for Publishing and Distribution.
Ibn Hajar al-Asghalani, Ahmad ibn Ali. 1994. Ethaf al-Mohrah be al-Fawaed al-Mobtakerah men Atraf al-Asharah, Researched by Tradition and Biography Center, Supervised by Zohayr ibn Naser al-Naser, Medina: King Fahd Assembly for the Printing of the Holy Qur’an (in Medina) & the Prophet's Tradition and Biography Center. [in Arabic]
Ibn Hajar al-Asghalani, Ahmad ibn Ali. 2012. Fath al-Bari Sharh Sahih al-Bokhari, Researched by Moheb al-Din al-Khatib, Beirut: Dar al-Ma‘refah. [in Arabic]
Ibn Hamdun, Mohammad ibn al-Hasan. 1996. Tazkerah al-Hamduniyah, Beirut: Dar Sadr. [in Arabic]
Ibn Hanbal al-Sheybani, Ahmad. 1983. Fazael al-Sahabah (Virtues of the Companions), Researched by D. Wasiyollah Mohammad Abbas, Beirut: Al-Resalah Institute. [in Arabic]
Ibn Hanbal al-Sheybani, Ahmad. 2000. Mosnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Researched by Shoayb Arnaut, Beirut: Al-Resalah Institute. [in Arabic]
Ibn Kathir al-Ghorashi, Esma‘il ibn Omar. 1990. Al-Bedayah wa al-Nehayah (The Beginning and the End), Beirut: The Teachings Library. [in Arabic]
Ibn Mardawayh al-Esfahani, Ahmad ibn Musa. 2003. Managheb Ali ibn Abi Taleb (AS) wa Ma Nozela men al-Qoran fi Ali (AS) (The Virtues of Ali ibn Abi Talib (AS) and What Was Revealed from the Quran about Him), Researched by Abd al-Razzagh Mohammad Hoseyn Herz al-Din, Qom: Dar al-Hadith. [in Arabic]
Johari Basri, Ahmad ibn Abd al-Aziz. n.d. Al-Saghifeh wa Fadak, Researched by Mohammad Hadi Amini, Tehran: Neynava Modern Library. [in Arabic]
Kashani, Fathollah ibn Shokrollah. 1336. Manhaj al-Sadeghayn fi Elzam al-Mokhalefin (The Method of the Honest in Convincing the Opponents), Tehran: Islamic Bookstore. [in Arabic]
Kharazmi, Mowaffagh ibn Ahmad. 1990. Al-Managheb (The Virtues), Qom: Islamic Publications Office Affiliated with Qom Seminary Teachers Association. [in Arabic]
Makarem Shirazi, Naser et al. 1993. Tafsir Nemuneh (Model Interpretation), Tehran: Islamic Books Institute. [in Farsi]
Makarem Shirazi, Naser. 2008. Payam Quran (The Message of the Quran), Tehran: Islamic Books Institute. [in Farsi]
Mofid, Mohammad ibn Mohammad. 1992. Al-Jamal wa al-Nosrah le Seyyed al-Etrah fi Harb al-Basrah (The Jamal and the Victory for the Master of the Household in the Basra War), Researched by Ali Mir Sharifi, Qom: Sheykh Mofid Congress. [in Arabic]
Sharani, Abu al-Hasan. 2008. Pajuhesh-hay Qorani Allameh Sha‘rani dar Tafasir Majma al-Bayan, Ruh al-Janan wa Manhaj al-Sadeghayn (Quranic Researches of Allameh Sha'rani on the Commentaries of Majma al-Bayan, Ruh al-Jannan and Manhaj al-Sadeghayn), Researched by Mohammad Reza Ghiyathi Kermani, Qom: Bustan Ketab. [in Farsi]
Sharif Al-Razi, Mohammad ibn Hoseyn. 1993. Nahj al-Balaghah, Researched by Saleh Sobhi, Qom: Hejrat. [in Arabic]
Soltani, Seyyed Ali Asghar. 1964. Ghudrat, Gofteman wa Zaban: Saz wa Karhay Jaryan Ghodrat dar Jomhuri Eslami (Power, discourse and language: mechanisms of the flow of power in the Islamic Republic), Tehran: Ney. [in Farsi]
Zahabi, Shams al-Din. 1987. Tarikh al-Eslam wa Wafayat al-Mashhir wa al-Alam (History of Islam and the Deaths of Figures and Personages), Researched by D. Omar Abd al-Salam Tadmori, Beirut: Arabic Book Institute. [in Arabic]