Journal of Imamiyyah Studies

Journal of Imamiyyah Studies

Typology of Readings and Approaches of ʿĀshūrā in Mashrūtih and Pahlavi Age

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
seyed mohsen tabatabaie 1
mohsen.. ranjbar 2
Seyyed Mohamad Hosseini 3
1 Phd student of Shiʿite studies, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran,
2 Associate professor, Imām Khomeini Education and Research Institute, Qom, Iran,
3 Phd of Shiʿite studies, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran,
Abstract
Attitude towards ʿĀshūrā, as one of the most important events in Shiʿite history in contemporary times, has taken different forms. In the meantime, the Mashrūṭih and Pahlavī eras have presented the most frequent inter-Imāmian discourses in the field. The present study seeks to answer the reason why for the formation of different types of readings and approaches of ʿĀshūrā based on the descriptive method of ritual studies and analysis of sociological readings of texts. According to the hypothesis of this research, Shiʿites in preserving the messages and consequences of this event after a period of chronology, gradually distancing themselves from the style of historiography and influenced by currents of thought, have had a tremendous impact on the type of maqtal writing with specific readings and approaches in later periods. The findings show that the evolution of religious discourse in the Shiʿite community influenced by modern developments and emerging currents, from the Mashrūṭih era to that of Pahlavī and gradually until the Islamic Revolution, has provided the basis for the formation of new readings and approaches. Multiple approaches derived from these newly discovered elements in various models such as martyrdom-seeking, political-revolutionary tendencies, etc. have been studied in this research.
Keywords
Reading
Approach
ʿĀshūrā
Mshrūṭih
Pahlavī

Ayati, Muḥammad Ibrahim (1381), Barrasī-yi tārīkh-i ʿAshūrā, bi kūshishi: Mahdi Ansari, Qom: Imām-i ʿaṣr.

Ibn Abi`l Ḥadīd, Ibrahīm (1404), Sharḥ-i nahj al-balāghah, Qom: Kitābkhāneh Marʿashī.
Ibn Aʿtham, Abū Muḥammad (1411), Al-Futūḥ, Ed. ʿAlīShiri, Beirut: Dār al-Aḍwaʾ.
Ibn Qūliwayh (1365). Kāmil al-ziyārāt, Najaf, Dār al-Murtaḍawiyah.
Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahānī, Alī ibn al- Ḥusayn (bī tā). Maqātil al- ṭalibīn, Ed. Seyyed Ahmad Saqar, Beirut: Dār al-Maʿrifah.
Abū Mikhnaf (1417). Waq`at al-Lutf, ed. Yusufi Gharavi, Qom: Jāmi`i-yi Mudarrisīn Hawzi-yi Ilmiyi-yi Qom.
Irbīlī, Abul Ḥasan Alī Ibn ʿIsa (1421). Kashf al-Ghommat fī Maʿrifat al-aʾimmah, Qom: Razī.
Asadī Tusī, Abu Nasr Alī ibn Aḥmad (1386). Garshāsb Nāmeh, ed. Habib Yaghmayi, Tehran: Dunyā-yi Kitāb.
Ishtihardi, Alipanah (1391). Kitāb-i haft sālih chirā sidā dar āvard, Qom: Ilmiyeh.
Ansari Qomi, Muḥammad ʿAlī(1350). Difā` az Husayn-i Shahīd: Radd bar Kitāb-i Shahīd-i Jāvīd, Qom, Mehr Ustuwar.
Burqiʿī, Seyyed Abulfazl (bī tā). Khurāfāt-i wufur dar ziyārāt-i Qubūr, bī jā, bī nā.
Poorjavadi, Nasrollah (1371). Ishqi Abadī wa bādiyi alast, in Nashr-i Dānish, s: 12, No. 3
Tābandeh Gonābādi, Soltān Ḥossein (1372). Tajalli-yi ḥaqiqat dar asrār-i fājiʿi-yi karbalā, Tehran: Ḥaqiqat.
Thomas, Michel (1377). Kalām-i Masīhī, Translated by: Hossein Tawfiqi, Qom: Markaz-i Mutali`at wa Tahqiqat Adyan wa Mazahib.
Jaʿfarian, Rasul (1383). Sāzmānhā-yi Madhḥabī Siyāsī-yi Iran-i Sālhā-yi 1320-1357, Tehran: Markaz-i Asnād-i Inqilāb-i Islāmi wa Pazhuheshgāh-i Farhang wa Andīshi-yi Islāmī. 
Haʾiri Mazanderani, Mulla Muḥammad Mahdi (1367). Maʿālī al-sibṭayn fī Ahwāl-i al-Ḥasan wa al-Husayn ʿalayhimā al-Slām, Qom: Sharīf Raḍī.
Husayni, Seyyed Muḥammad (1397). Āsībshinasī-yi Muṭaliʿat-i mu`aṣir-i ʿĀshūra, Risāli-yi Dukturī Tārīkh-i Tashyyuʿ-i Ithnā `Asharī, Ustād Rāhnamā: Ni`matullāh Safari Furūshānī, Ustād Mushavir: ʿAlī Āqānūrī, Qom: Dānishgāh-i Adyān wa Madhāhib.
Hakamizadeh, Aliakbar (Bi tā). Asrār-i Hizār Salih, Bi ja, Bi na.
Khāliṣizādeh, Muḥammad (1382). Falsafi-yi qiyām-i Muqaddas-i Ḥusaynī: Sharḥ-i ḥadith-i Ḥusaynun Minni wa Ana min Ḥusainin, Qom: Bi na.
Rezaei, Ahmad (1350). Rah-i Husayn, Tehran: Bi na.
Ranjbar, Mohsen (1392). Jarayān shināsī-yi tārīkhī-yi qarā`athā wa Rūykardhā-yi ʿĀshūrā az Safawiyih tā Mashrūṭih bā ta`kid bar maqātil, Qom: Muʾassisi-yi Āmūzishī wa Pazhūhishī-yi Imām Khomeini.
Sayyid ibn Tawūs, Raḍī al-Dīn Alī (1348), al-Malhūf ʿalā qatl al-ṭufūf, Tehran: Jāhān.
Shariat Sangaljī, Muḥammad Ḥasan (1322), Maḥw al-humūm, Tehran: Tābān.
Shariati, ʿAlī(1346), Ḥusayn wārith-i Ādam, in: Majmūʿih āthār, Tehran: Qalam, Vol. 19.
_________ (1350), Qūmū, Tehran: Ḥuseiniyah-i Irshād.
Shariati, Muḥammad Taqi (1375), Chirā ḥusayn qiyām kard?, Tehran: Biʿthat.
Sharif Kashani, Mulla Ḥbibullah (1336), Nukhbat al-maṣāʾib, Tehran: Maṭbaʿat Musawi.
_________ (1384). Tadhkirat al-shuhadā, bā hamkārī-yi: Abbas Mommad Qolian, Tehran: Shams al-ḍuḥa.
_________ (1387), Asrarun ḥusayniyah, bi kūshish-i: Hossein Dargahi, Tehran: bī nā.
 
Ṣafi Golpaygani, Lotfollah (1315). Partuwī az aẓamat-i Ḥusayn, Tehran: Ṣadr.
_________ (bī tā). Ḥusayn ibn ʿAlī(a), Shahīd-i āgāh wa rahbar-i nejātbakhsh-i Islām, Tehran: Kitābkhānah-i Ṣadr.
Ṣalehi Najafabadi, Ni`matollah (1361). Shahīd Jāwīd, Tehran: Rasā.
__________ (1386). Taṭbīq-i Qiyam-i Imām Ḥusayn (a) bā mawāzīn-i feqhi dar qiḍāwat-i zan dar fiqh-i Islāmi, Tehran: Ommīd-i farad.
Ṣafāʾī Ḥāʾirī, ʿAbbās (1379). Tārīkh-i Sayyid al-shuhadā, Qom: Jamkarān.
Ṭabarī, Abū Jaʿfar Muḥammad Jarīr (1387). Tarīkh al-umam wa`lmulūk, Ed. Muḥammad Abolfazl Ibrahīm, Beirut: Dār al-turāth.
Ṭūsī, Muammad ibn Ḥasan (1414). Al-Amālī, Qom: Dār al-thiqāfah.
 Qalamdārān, Heidar ʿAlī(bī tā alif) Rāh-i nijāt az sharr-i Ghulāt, bī jā, bī nā. 
___________ (bī tā be). Shāh rāh-i ittihād, bī jā, bī nā.
___________ (bī tā jīm). Armaghān-i āsimān, bī jā, bī nā.
Qommi, Shaykh Abbas (1379). Nafas al-humūm fī muṣībat-i sayyidina al-Ḥusain al-maẓlūm, Qom: Maktabat al-Ḥaydariyah.
Kasirer, Irnist (1362). Afsānih-i dawlat, Khwārazmī.
Kashifī, Ḥosein ibn ʿAlī(1382). Rawḍat al-shuhadā, Taṣḥiḥ: ʿAqīqī Bakhshāyeshī, Qom: Navīd Islām.
Kasrawī, Ahmad (1322). Shīʿīgarī, Tehran: Peymān.
kamarihʾī, Mirza Khalil (1389 alif), ʿUnsur-i shujʿat, Qom: Dar al-ʿrfān.
___________ (1389 be). Yik shab wa rūz-i ʿāshūra, Qom: Dar al-ʿrfān.
Ilgār, Ḥāmid (1371). Kambirij, Silsili-yi Pahlawī wa nīrūha-yi madhhabī dar Iran-i qarn-i bīstum, Tehran: Ṭarh-i naw.
Lak, Manuchehr (1384), »Darāmadī bar shinākht-i ustūrih wa tabyīīn-i kārkardhā-yi huwiyyatbakhsh-i ān dar shiʿr-i jang« in: muṭāliʿāt-i Millī, s. 6. no. 3, pp. 63-84.    
Mārbīn Almanī (1333). Siyāsat al- Ḥusainiyyah, bī jā, bī nā.
Muṭahharī, Murtaḍā (1372). Ḥimāsi-yi Ḥusayni, in: Majmūʿ-yi āthār, Qom: Ṣadrā, vol. 17. 
Mozaffari, Ayat (1385). Jarayān shināsī-yi Iran-i muʿāṣir, Qom: Zamzam-i hidayat.
Mawlawī (1397), Guzidi-yi ghazalīāyt-i Shams, bi kūshish-i: Shafiʿī Kadkanī, Tehran: Amīrkabīr.
Naẓim `l-Islam Kirmānī, Mīrzā Muḥammad (1371). Tārīkh-i bīdarī-yi Īranīan yā tārīkh-i mashrūḥ wa ḥaqīqī-yi mashrūṭiyyat-i Iran, Tehran: Amīrkabīr.   
Haks, Jeimz (1377). Qāmūs-i kitāb-i muqaddas, Tehran, Asātīr.
Yaʿqūbi (bī tā). Tārīkh, Beirut: Dār sādir.
Journal of Imamiyyah Studies
Volume 6, Issue 11 - Serial Number 11
September 2020
Pages 34-62